Nitrate contamination of drinking water is a widespread concern and threatens human health. The magnitude of the health consequences depends on individuals’ ability to avoid exposure. This paper uses an event-study framework to uncover avoidance behavior and infant mortality outcomes following Safe Drinking Water Act nitrate violations. Using store-level scanner data, I estimate that consumers spend $4.5 million annually on bottled water to avoid nitrate-contaminated drinking water. This protective behavior leads to 14 avoided infant deaths per year or $160 million in monetized benefits. These results underscore the benefits of avoiding nitrate-contaminated drinking water exceed the costs incurred by consumers.